Reading time 21 Minutes

The voices of experts, journalists and activists – COP30 is better than a complete failure (Part 3)

5. Expert interview: Claudia Kemfert, climate economist

The headline is slightly depressing: β€žFossil fuel blockers are slowing things down – society has long since moved on.β€œ This tension runs through the entire report, in which climate economist Claudia Kemfert looks back on COP30 – and as you listen, you realise that this is not just another sober recap of the climate summit, but a pretty clear reality check on where we stand as a global community. 1 Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert – β€žFossil fuel blockers are slowing things down – society has long since moved onβ€œ 🌐 https://youtu.be/DyDqbC9z6mc

Instead of celebrations over historic breakthroughs, BelΓ©m has produced a β€žminimal diplomatic consensusβ€œ. COP30 is better than a complete failure – but it falls miles short of what science demands for a reasonably safe course of action.2 Federal Environment Agency – UN Climate Conference COP30: No breakthrough, but small steps 🌐https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/en/topics/un-climate-conference-cop30-no-breakthrough-but While forests burn, coasts are flooded and heat waves paralyse cities, delegates in conference rooms struggle to find wording that will hurt fossil fuel companies as little as possible.

Photo: The consequences of extreme weather are also noticeable in Germany. Flooding caused by heavy rainfall at NeckargemΓΌnd on the Neckar River in southern Germany. – trinculo_photo / iStock by GettyImages

COP30: When even a β€žminimal basisβ€œ is considered progress
The UN Climate Secretariat calculates what Kemfert classifies politically in the podcast: even if all currently available climate plans (NDCs) were fully implemented, global emissions would fall by just 12 per cent below 2019 levels by 2035.3 UNFCCC – Update to NDC Synthesis Report shows the emissions curve is being bent downwards, but urgent 🌐https://unfccc.int/news/update-to-ndc-synthesis-report-shows-the-emissions-curve-is-being-bent-downwards-but-urgent However, a 1.5-degree pathway would require reductions of around 60 per cent over the same period – five times what is currently on the table.4 IPCC – AR6 Synthesis Report, Summary for Policymakers 🌐https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/syr/

Photo: falling graph showing the reduction in CO2 emissions, drawing of planet Earth. Motion blur of blue, snow-covered mountains in the background. – mi-viri / iStock by GettyImages

The EU Commission politely calls the result β€ža very minimal basis for global action,β€œ but at the same time emphasises that the pace β€žis far from meeting the urgency of the climate crisis.β€œ.5 EU Climate Action – What did COP30 achieve? 🌐https://climate.ec.europa.eu/news-other-reads/news/what-did-cop30-achieve-2025-12-01_en The climate movement, scientists and many communities in the Global South are much harsher in their judgement. More than 80 countries had demanded a clear roadmap for phasing out coal, oil and gas; in the end, the text contains a watered-down commitment to a β€žtransition away from fossil fuelsβ€œ, full of loopholes and room for interpretation.6 IISD – COP 30 Outcome: What it means and what’s next 🌐 https://www.iisd.org/articles/insight/cop-30-outcome-what-it-means-and-whats-next

Photo: Bergheim-Niederaußem lignite-fired power station in the Rhenish mining area in North Rhine-Westphalia. 7 Niederaußem lignite-fired power station 🌐 https://www.rwe.com/der-konzern/laender-und-standorte/kraftwerk-niederaussem/ With a total net output of around 3.4 GW, Niederaußem was long the second most powerful coal-fired power station in Germany after Neurath. 8 Greenpeace, Coal Commission: Greenpeace calls for power stations to be shut down 🌐 https://www.greenpeace.de/klimaschutz/energiewende/kohleausstieg/niederaussem  Several older units have already been decommissioned as part of the coal phase-out; operator RWE describes the shutdown path until 2030 on its website. 9 Niederaußem lignite-fired power station 🌐 https://www.rwe.com/der-konzern/laender-und-standorte/kraftwerk-niederaussem/ – Oliver Oltmanns / iStock by GettyImages

For the first time: the global end for fossil fuels – but not really
Sounds great at first: for the first time, all countries recognise that fossil fuels have no long-term future and that the world must move away from fossil fuels.10uronews Green – From deforestation to fossil fuels: What did countries actually agree on at COP30 🌐https://www.euronews.com/green/2025/11/24/from-deforestation-to-fossil-fuels-what-did-countries-actually-agree-on-at-cop30 But the details paint a bleak picture: no clear end dates for coal, oil and gas, no commitment to halt new fossil fuel projects, no binding reduction in fossil fuel subsidies.

Graphic: End of subsidies for fossil fuels, illustration and infographic. –monkik / iStock by GettyImages

Organisations such as Deutsche Umwelthilfe (DUH) speak of β€žwatered-down decisionsβ€œ on phasing out fossil fuels – measured against physical necessities, the resolutions to end fossil fuels and deforestation fall far short of what is needed. 11 ESG News Earth – COP30 Outcomes Draw Global Criticism as Scientists Warn Climate Action Remains Insufficient 🌐 https://esgnews.com/cop30-outcomes-draw-global-criticism-as-scientists-warn-climate-action-remains-insufficient/ That is precisely what Kemfert is saying: yes, there has been progress on paper. But no, this COP has not really brought the world any closer to the 1.5-degree path. 12 Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert – β€žFossil fuel blockers are slowing things down – society has long since moved onβ€œ 🌐https://youtu.be/DyDqbC9z6mc

At this point, I would like to warmly recommend the podcast β€žDer Klimakompass mit Claudia Kemfertβ€œ (The Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert). It's getting too warm anyway, and this podcast addresses many important issues relating to global warming. The pun with the warm recommendation didn't land, did it? Too bad, I thought it was a good one.

Be that as it may. On the energy transition under Merz13 The Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert, Delaying tactics? The energy transition under Merz 🌐 https://youtu.be/D9EtX4v66dI about the never-ending story of the alleged end of combustion engines14 The Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert: U-turn on the end of combustion engines? 🌐 https://youtu.be/vROeDZ-YG_k right up to these very consequences for COP3015 The Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert, COP30: No conference is not a solution either 🌐 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a3bpQ1xrEpI&t=6s and the current situation in the world16 The Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert, Fossil fuel blockers are slowing things down – society has long since moved on 🌐 https://youtu.be/DyDqbC9z6mc There have already been several exciting episodes. Seven, to be precise. 17 The Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert 🌐 https://www.youtube.com/@klimakompass Which is a shame, because I watched all seven episodes in just two days and now I can hardly wait for the next one to come out.

Graphic: Screenshot of the YouTube thumbnail β€œSlowing down fossil fuel blockers – society has long since moved onβ€œ from The Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert available online at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DyDqbC9z6mc accessed on 8 December 2025. Editorial use. 18 The Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert, Fossil fuel blockers are slowing things down – society has long since moved on 🌐 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DyDqbC9z6mc

Brazil between forest protection and new oil drilling
BelΓ©m in the state of ParΓ‘, in the heart of the Amazon, was intended to be a symbol: host country Brazil wanted to put forest protection, indigenous rights and climate justice front and centre.19 Conclusion of the COP30 World Climate Protection Conference | Federal Government 🌐 https://www.bundesregierung.de/breg-de/aktuelles/abschluss-cop30-2395690 This has been partially successful – from the visibility of indigenous delegations to the announcement of forest protection initiatives. At the same time, Brazil issued new licences for offshore oil drilling during the COP and continues to emphasise that oil and gas exports are a key pillar of its own economy. 20 Euronews Green – From deforestation to fossil fuels 🌐https://www.euronews.com/green/2025/11/24/from-deforestation-to-fossil-fuels-what-did-countries-actually-agree-on-at-cop30

Photo: Offshore burner boom on an oil rig, Campos Basin, Brazil. – Alvaro Victor / iStock by GettyImages

Particularly controversial, but politically skilfully staged, is the Tropical Forest Forever Facility – a multi-billion-euro fund outside the UN framework that will pay Brazil and partner countries to leave forests standing. Germany has already pledged to contribute one billion euros to this fund over ten years; Norway intends to contribute the equivalent of around 2.5 billion euros in the form of loans if other donors follow suit.21 Euronews Green – From deforestation to fossil fuels 🌐 https://www.euronews.com/green/2025/11/24/from-deforestation-to-fossil-fuels-what-did-countries-actually-agree-on-at-cop30 That's important – but it's only one side of the coin: you can't sell credible forest protection and at the same time expand new fossil fuel projects in the same country without running into massive credibility problems. Kemfert points out this contradiction very clearly – and you can sense how difficult it is to see a country as both a beacon of hope and an obstacle at the same time. 22 Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert – β€žFossil fuel blockers are slowing things down – society has long since moved onβ€œ 🌐 https://youtu.be/DyDqbC9z6mc

Graphic: Image of the Brazilian flag, oil pump, oil rig and barrels with rising graph, symbolising the concept of oil production in Brazil. – MARHARYTA MARKO / iStock by GettyImages

Germany: β€žsolidβ€œ in terms of climate diplomacy, but far below what is needed
And Germany? The report makes it clear that the German government arrived with a few visible financial commitments, but without any intention of really taking on a leadership role. At COP30, Germany pledged to contribute an additional €60 million to the international adaptation fund – and points out that it has been the largest donor there for years. According to the Ministry of the Environment, Germany's climate adaptation funding from the federal budget for 2024 totalled 2.84 billion euros. 23 COP 30 – Climate adaptation: Germany provides €60 million for the Global Climate Change Adaptation Fund – BMUKN – Press release. Federal Ministry for the Environment 🌐 https://www.bundesumweltministerium.de/pressemitteilung/cop-30-klimaanpassung-deutschland-stellt-60-millionen-euro-fuer-den-globalen-anpassungsfonds-bereit

It sounds like a lot, but measured against global demand, it is simply not enough. UNEP estimates that countries in the Global South will need between 310 and 365 billion US dollars annually for climate adaptation alone by 2035, while international public adaptation funding amounted to just 26 billion US dollars in 2023.24 UNEP – Adaptation Gap Report 2025: Running on Empty (summary) 🌐https://greeningtheblue.org/stories/uneps-adaptation-gap-report-2025-warns-running-empty-adaptation-finance 25 GKToday – UNEP Adaptation Gap Report (AGR) 2025 🌐https://www.gktoday.in/unep-adaptation-gap-report-agr-2025/ The gap in adaptation financing alone is therefore somewhere between 284 and just under 340 billion US dollars per year – money that is simply not available today.26 Climate.Table – Climate adaptation: UNEP expects a shortfall of at least USD 284 billion in 2035 🌐https://table.media/en/climate/feature/climate-adaptation-unep-expects-a-shortfall-of-at-least-usd-284-billion-in-2035

Kemfert describes what was decided in BelΓ©m as β€žsymbolic progressβ€œ. The states have acknowledged that adaptation funding would need to be roughly tripled by 2035 – but without a clear baseline figure, without a binding distribution formula and without legally enforceable obligations. 27 UNFCCC – Matters relating to adaptation: National adaptation plans. Proposal by the Presidency 🌐https://unfccc.int/documents/654945 28 UNFCCC – Unlocking Climate Finance for Adaptation in the Caribbean Region CN 🌐 https://unfccc.int/documents/655133 29 Mirwald, M., Schwarz, R., Adaptation at COP30 – Getting Ready for Implementation on the Ground While β€˜Running on Empty’? 🌐 https://www.germanwatch.org/de/blog/anpassung-auf-der-cop30 30 Mirwald, M., Schwarz, R., Adaptation at COP30 – Getting Ready for Implementation on the Ground While β€˜Running on Empty’? 🌐https://www.germanwatch.org/en/node/93327 Politically, this is a signal; financially, it is far removed from the reality in which people are losing their homes, crops and livelihoods.

Photo: Aerial view 1 of the small town of Silchar, Assam, India. Rural neighbourhood flooded with mud by the Barak River on 19 May 2022. – Rahul Dsilva / iStock by GettyImages
Photo: Aerial view 2 of the small town of Silchar, Assam, India, natural disaster in the Global South as a result of climate change. – Rahul Dsilva / iStock by GettyImages

A trillion for the South – and a whole lot of excuses in the North
The programme repeatedly mentions the figure of around one trillion US dollars that countries in the Global South would need per year for climate protection and adaptation.31 Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert – β€žFossil fuel blockers are slowing things down – society has long since moved onβ€œ 🌐https://youtu.be/DyDqbC9z6mc Civil society networks such as CAN International are calling for the new global climate finance target (NCQG) to be at least US$300 billion per year for adaptation alone – and significantly higher overall if emission reductions are also included. 32 Climate Action Network – Briefing: A New Adaptation Finance Commitment under the Global Goal on Adaptation 🌐https://climatenetwork.org/resource/briefing-a-new-adaptation-finance-commitment-under-the-global-goal-on-adaptation/ UNEP, in turn, estimates that the pure adaptation costs could even reach 440 to 520 billion US dollars annually by 2035, adjusted for inflation.33 UNEP – Adaptation Gap Report 2025 (detailed analysis) 🌐 https://www.weadapt.org/knowledge-base/governance-institutions-and-policy/unep-adaptation-gap-report-2025-running-on-empty/

At the same time, even before COP30, the Baku BelΓ©m Roadmap had already raised the issue of a climate financing target of 1.3 trillion US dollars by 2035 – a mix of public and private financing, but it remains completely unclear how much of this is actually additional and to what extent debt traps for the South can be avoided. 34 UNEP – Adaptation Gap Report 2025: Running on Empty (reference to Baku–BelΓ©m Roadmap) 🌐 https://www.gktoday.in/unep-adaptation-gap-report-agr-2025/ In BelΓ©m, this target was not definitively enshrined in policy – but it remains a figure that makes one thing clear: if wealthy countries want to, they can find the money. The question is not β€žwhetherβ€œ but β€žwho pays – and under what conditionsβ€œ.

China between world record solar power and coal dependency
A particularly exciting strand of the report is devoted to China. Kemfert vividly describes how contradictory the country's role is: no new, significantly stricter climate targets at COP30, no accelerated phase-out of coal – but a massive expansion of renewable energies, which is already growing faster than the country's own electricity demand. 35 Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert – β€žFossil fuel blockers are slowing things down – society has long since moved onβ€œ 🌐 https://youtu.be/DyDqbC9z6mc

 
 
We've heard about it, yes. But it's impossible to truly comprehend and grasp the scale at which China is pushing ahead with the expansion of renewable energies. China's largest solar park at present is a new mega-project in the desert near ÜrΓΌmqi in the Xinjiang region. In 2024, the Midong Solar Park (sometimes simply referred to as the β€žlargest solar farm near Urumqi/Xinjiangβ€œ) was connected to the grid there.

The plant has an installed capacity of around 3.5 gigawatts (3,500 MW) and covers approximately 33,000 hectares of desert land. According to the operators, it generates around 6.1 billion kWh of electricity per year, enough to cover the Balearic Islands' annual consumption of around 5–6 TWh. 36 Number of tourists on the Balearic Islands, Spain from 2017 to 2024, by main origin 🌐https://www.statista.com/statistics/772140/annual-number-of-tourists-arriving-in-the-balearic-islands-by-origin/ 37 Balearic Islands on track to record tourist arrivals in 2023 🌐 https://mallorcaglobalmag.es/en/baleares-camino-de-registrar-record-de-llegadas-de-turistas-en-2023 Just to remind you, wink smiley, the Balearic Islands are the Mediterranean islands of Mallorca, Menorca, Ibiza and Formentera. All of them. With just one solar park. And it's not just the inhabitants of all the islands combined who are electricity consumers. We're talking about around 17.9 million tourists every year.38 National electrical energy balance (generation mix) 🌐 https://electrek.co/2024/06/04/worlds-largest-solar-farm-china/
 

Photo: Solar power plant in the snow in winter, Xinjiang, China, Asia. – Zhang Mengyang / iStock by GettyImages

In its World Energy Outlook, the International Energy Agency confirms that China is the global leader in the expansion of wind and solar energy and will have installed more new solar capacity annually than the rest of the world combined by 2024/2025.39 IEA – World Energy Outlook 2025 (China factsheet) 🌐 https://www.iea.org/reports/world-energy-outlook-2025 At the same time, the country remains the world's largest consumer of coal and continues to build new coal-fired power stations, citing energy security and industrial competitiveness among other reasons.40 IEA – Coal 2024 🌐https://www.iea.org/reports/coal-2024 41 IEA (2024), Coal 2024, IEA, Paris https://www.iea.org/reports/coal-2024, Licence: CC BY 4.0 🌐 https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/a1ee7b75-d555-49b6-b580-17d64ccc8365/Coal2024.pdf This makes China a deeply ambivalent player: a driver of the global energy transition – and at the same time a major driver of climate change.

Kemfert describes how China tends to be rather cautious on the international stage, rarely promising more than it can deliver – and, unlike some Western countries, is known for actually keeping its promises.42 Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert – β€žFossil fuel blockers are slowing things down – society has long since moved onβ€œ 🌐https://youtu.be/DyDqbC9z6mc For climate policy, this means that if China commits more seriously and earlier to a faster phase-out of coal, there is a high chance that this will actually happen. However, there is still a huge gap between its technological leadership in renewables and the fossil fuel reality in its electricity mix.

Graphic: Coal-fired power station with Chinese national flag superimposed. – Sunshine Seeds / iStock by GettyImages

Carbon Markets: Between Climate Protection Instrument and Climate Colonialism
At COP30, the Open Coalition on Compliance Carbon Markets was announced – a coalition of 18 countries to date, including Brazil, EU countries (including Germany) and China, which aims to better link state-regulated emissions trading systems and make COβ‚‚ prices a stronger lever. 43 COP30 – Carbon Market Coalition welcomes 18 member countries at COP30 🌐 https://cop30.br/en/news-about-cop30/carbon-market-coalition-welcomes-18-member-countries-at-cop30

In theory, emissions trading and carbon markets can help reduce emissions where it is most cost-effective and channel money into nature-based solutions such as forest protection, reforestation and peatland restoration – areas that, according to the IPCC, could deliver up to a third of the global emissions reductions needed. 44 IPCC – AR6 WGIII: Climate Change 2022 – Mitigation of Climate Change (chapter on agriculture and forestry) 🌐https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg3/ However, the reality of recent years has often been one of opaque projects, dubious certificates, double counting and cases in which indigenous communities have lost land rights in the name of β€žclimate protectionβ€œ. I have already written an interesting article on this topic, which you can find here: Africa: safaris and good business 45 Africa: Safaris and good business 🌐 https://paddys.de/afrika-safaris-und-gute-geschaefte/

This is precisely why environmental organisations warn that new market architectures without strict human rights, biodiversity and integrity standards could actually reinforce β€žclimate colonialismβ€œ: rich countries buy their way out, while the South loses land, sovereignty and often real emissions reductions.46 Nature4Climate – COP 30 Delivers Progress β€” But Seems to Have Missed its Moment 🌐https://nature4climate.org/cop-30-delivers-progress-but-seems-to-have-missed-its-moment/ Kemfert emphasises that carbon markets should only be an additional tool – not a free pass to continue building fossil fuel infrastructure and water down the phase-out with compensation measures.47 Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert – β€žFossil fuel blockers are slowing things down – society has long since moved onβ€œ 🌐https://youtu.be/DyDqbC9z6mc

Graphic: Banner reading tip β€žAfrica: Safaris and good businessβ€œ

Society has long since moved on: 83 per cent are concerned
The strongest counterpoint to all these obstacles in the report does not come from the negotiating tents, but from society. The second cohesion report by the Research Institute for Social Cohesion (FGZ) shows that 83 per cent of people in Germany are concerned about the consequences of the climate crisis, and 71 per cent believe that politicians should do more to protect the climate.48 Research Institute for Social Cohesion – (Im)possible transformation? Second Cohesion Report 🌐 https://fgz-risc.de/fileadmin/media/publikationen/Zweiter_Zusammenhaltsbericht/Zweiter_Zusammenhaltsbericht_FGZ_web.pdf 49 University of Bremen – Research Institute Social Cohesion: Majority of Germans Willing to Support Climate Action 🌐 https://www.uni-bremen.de/en/university/university-communication-and-marketing/all-news/details/research-institute-social-cohesion-majority-of-germans-willing-to-support-climate-action

The researchers distinguish between five β€žclimate typesβ€œ:

Ever since I first heard about the five climate types, I have been wondering which of the five types applies to me. You can tick multiple answers, but the climate types are mutually exclusive. So I can't be concerned and at the same time be one of the determined – which I am with what I do, i.e. writing, educating, organising fundraising campaigns with five-figure donations, even privately – oh, you don't even want to know how much I donate every year, while others fly to the Caribbean with the whole family in the summer for two weeks of diving. Yes, that's about right. A skiing holiday in Switzerland might also be possible. Yes, I probably count myself among the determined. Among those determined people who agree with concern and obviously cannot be pigeonholed. Winking smiley.

The opposing group – i.e. those who fundamentally oppose climate policy, are heavily influenced by disinformation narratives and are mostly politically right-wing to far-right – only accounts for around eight per cent, but is extremely vocal and overrepresented on social media and in parts of the traditional media. 51 University of Bremen – Majority of Germans willing to do more for climate protection 🌐 https://www.uni-bremen.de/universitaet/hochschulkommunikation-und-marketing/aktuelle-meldungen/detailansicht/forschungszentrum-gesellschaftlicher-zusammenhalt-mehrheit-der-deutschen-zu-mehr-klimaschutz-bereit 52 Richter, Christoph, Axel Salheiser, Noah Marschner, and Janine Patz. 2024. Climate of Regression: Public Climate Attitudes and Radical Right Anti-Climate Mobilisation in the Battle Around the Green Transition in Germany. In: Contested Climate Justice – Challenged Democracy: International Perspectives, edited by Noah Marschner, Christoph Richter, Janine Patz and Axel Salheiser, 235–259. 1st edition. Social Cohesion 9. Frankfurt: Campus, 18 September 2024. url: https://www.campus.de/buecher-campus-verlag/wissenschaft/soziologie/contested_climate_justice_challenged_democracy-18004.html. 🌐 https://fgz-risc.de/bibliothek/publikationsdatenbank/details/climate-of-regression-public-climate-attitudes-and-radical-right-an 53 Contested Climate Justice – Challenged Democracy 🌐 https://www.campus.de/e-books/wissenschaft/contested_climate_justice_challenged_democracy-18364.html

Kemfert links this to her own experience in the podcast: for years, the majority of people at her lectures and readings have been clearly climate-conscious and open to change – the radical obstructionists tend to appear in online shitstorms rather than in the lecture hall.54 Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert – β€žFossil fuel blockers are slowing things down – society has long since moved onβ€œ 🌐 https://youtu.be/DyDqbC9z6mc The real divide is therefore not between β€žclimate deniersβ€œ and β€žclimate savioursβ€œ, but between a broad, often uncertain climate protection majority and a small but well-organised minority that makes professional use of disinformation.

Photo: Waigaoqiao Power Station is a huge coal-fired power station in the Gaodong Town district of Pudong, Shanghai. 55 Waigaoqiao power station 🌐 https://www.gem.wiki/Waigaoqiao_power_station  The plant currently has an installed capacity of around 5.1 GW, making it one of the largest coal-fired power stations in the world. 56 Waigaoqiao Power Station 🌐 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waigaoqiao_Power_Station  The power station was constructed in three phases between 1994 and 2008; the Phase III units operate using ultra-supercritical technology and achieve efficiencies of around 45–46%, making them particularly β€žefficientβ€œ – but still very COβ‚‚ intensive – makes charcoal kilns. 57 Waigaoqiao Power Station, Shanghai 🌐 https://www.power-technology.com/projects/waigaoqiao-power-station-shanghai/ 

Fear of division – and yet a clear majority in favour of climate protection
It is interesting to note that the same studies show that around 70 per cent of people in Germany are concerned that climate policy could further divide society. 58 University of Bremen – β€žMajority of Germans willing to do more for climate protectionβ€œ 🌐https://www.uni-bremen.de/universitaet/hochschulkommunikation-und-marketing/aktuelle-meldungen/detailansicht/forschungszentrum-gesellschaftlicher-zusammenhalt-mehrheit-der-deutschen-zu-mehr-klimaschutz-bereit Many are therefore in favour of greater climate protection but at the same time concerned about the social consequences – such as rising prices, the threat of job losses and inequalities between urban and rural areas.

The FGZ report shows that the β€žconcernedβ€œ in particular play a key role: they share the climate concerns of the determined, but have similarly strong social concerns as the rejecters. 59 Research Institute for Social Cohesion – (Im)possible transformation? Second Cohesion Report 🌐 https://fgz-risc.de/fileadmin/media/publikationen/Zweiter_Zusammenhaltsbericht/Zweiter_Zusammenhaltsbericht_FGZ_web.pdf If climate policy is not socially cushioned, they are susceptible to campaigns that frame every measure as β€žclimate dictatorship.β€œ If, on the other hand, climate policy visibly secures jobs, reduces energy poverty and includes regions, these very people can become a strong alliance for socio-ecological transformation.

Kemfert therefore makes a very clear demand: We must finally stop pretending in talk shows and headlines that Germany is β€žwidely dividedβ€œ on climate issues. The data tells a different story – and every editorial team that consistently highlights this 70 to 80 per cent majority strengthens social support for consistent climate protection. 60 DIW Berlin – More cohesion on climate issues? 🌐 https://www.diw.de/en/diw_01.c.988598.en/more_cohesion_on_climate_issues.html 61 Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert – β€žFossil fuel blockers are slowing things down – society has long since moved onβ€œ 🌐 https://youtu.be/DyDqbC9z6mc

Media logic vs. climate reality
A particularly honest moment in the report is the discussion about the media. Yes, good stories need friction. Yes, β€žEveryone agrees that climate protection is importantβ€œ doesn't sound like a ratings hit at first. But when editorial offices repeatedly artificially craft β€žtwo equally sized campsβ€œ out of a loud eight per cent minority and a 70 per cent majority, the result is a completely distorted picture. 62 University of Bremen – β€žMajority of Germans willing to do more for climate protectionβ€œ 🌐 https://www.uni-bremen.de/universitaet/hochschulkommunikation-und-marketing/aktuelle-meldungen/detailansicht/forschungszentrum-gesellschaftlicher-zusammenhalt-mehrheit-der-deutschen-zu-mehr-klimaschutz-bereit

Drawing on 25 years of media experience, Kemfert describes how she is practically never asked, β€žWhat will it cost us if we do nothing?β€œ but almost always, β€žWhat will climate protection cost us?β€œ.63 Climate Compass with Claudia Kemfert – β€žFossil fuel blockers are slowing things down – society has long since moved onβ€œ 🌐https://youtu.be/DyDqbC9z6mc The fact that failure to adapt to the climate crisis will cause trillions in future damage, according to the UNEP and the World Bank – from destroyed crops and flooding to healthcare costs – rarely receives the same media attention as complaints about COβ‚‚ prices.64 UNEP – Adaptation Gap Report 2025: Running on Empty 🌐 https://greeningtheblue.org/stories/uneps-adaptation-gap-report-2025-warns-running-empty-adaptation-finance
This is precisely where the report comes in: it encourages us to change the narrative – away from β€žWhat do we lose through climate protection?β€œ to β€žWhat do we gain through a just transition – and what do we lose if we continue to allow ourselves to be held back?β€œ.

Photo: Power stations such as Waigaoqiao Power Station in Shanghai are expected to burn around 40 shiploads of fossil coal per year. 65 Waigaoqiao Power Station, Shanghai 🌐 https://www.power-technology.com/projects/waigaoqiao-power-station-shanghai/ [ footnote] Waigaoqiao Power Station 🌐   https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waigaoqiao_Power_Station [/footnote] How else could such quantities be transported to the power station if not by ship? Aerial view of coal being loaded from barges. – Farhan Kudo San / iStock by GettyImages

Between anger and hope: What you can take away from this report
Perhaps after listening to this episode, you will sit there and feel a knot in your stomach. On the one hand, there is the reality of the COP30 negotiations, which have effectively pushed the 1.5-degree target into the distant future, a grotesque financing gap, watered-down resolutions and fossil fuel blockers who would rather cling to oil and gas profits than protect human lives. 66 UNFCCC – Update to NDC Synthesis Report 🌐https://unfccc.int/news/update-to-ndc-synthesis-report-shows-the-emissions-curve-is-being-bent-downwards-but-urgent 67 UNEP – Adaptation Gap Report 2025: Running on Empty 🌐https://greeningtheblue.org/stories/uneps-adaptation-gap-report-2025-warns-running-empty-adaptation-finance

Photo: β€žPanamaxβ€œ refers to ships whose dimensions are chosen so that they can just fit through the original locks of the Panama Canal (max. approx. 294 m in length, 32.3 m in width, 12 m in draught). 68 Panamax 🌐  https://www.industrie-lexikon.de/cms/lexikon/50-lexikon-p/3654-panamax.html Many coal carriers are in the range of 65,000–85,000 tonnes.69 Panamax 🌐 https://www.marbrokers.com/ship-types/panamax  , which is roughly equivalent to the weekly demand of the Waigaoqiao Power Station. These dimensions are almost impossible to imagine. – Askolds / iStock by GettyImages
Photo: Modern coal freight wagons (hoppers/gondolas) typically have a payload capacity of 60–80 tonnes; specialised coal wagons often have a capacity of 80 tonnes. 70 Coal hopper wagons 🌐  https://railwaywagons.com/rail-freight-wagons/hopper-wagons/coal-hopper-wagons/ So, to transport 80,000 tonnes of hard coal from the mining area to the port, you need 1,000 to 1,300 freight wagons per year. Okay, that's not really tangible either. – Askolds / iStock by GettyImages
Photo: Coal port transhipment terminal. Despite the immense expansion of renewable energies, the scale on which China burns fossil fuels remains enormous. This single power station alone is likely to consume 200 tonnes of coal per day. 71 Waigaoqiao Power Station, Shanghai 🌐 https://www.power-technology.com/projects/waigaoqiao-power-station-shanghai/ [ footnote] Waigaoqiao Power Station 🌐   https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waigaoqiao_Power_Station [/footnote]– Askolds / iStock by GettyImages

 

On a side note, you may have noticed that I am extremely cautious when it comes to figures and data from China. This is simply because there is hardly any relevant publicly available data from China on such far-fetched questions as, for example: How many square metres of rainforest would the Chinese government have to protect just to offset the COβ‚‚ emissions of this single power plant in Shanghai? I did a few calculations using the sparse data from the linked sources.

Photo: Chinese flag against a backdrop of coal. I have one more superlative figure to share. Well, perhaps it would be more accurate to say a negative superlative. Realistically, Waigaoqiao probably emits somewhere between 7 and 10 million tonnes of COβ‚‚ annually – just this one power plant. We recently talked about COβ‚‚ certificate trading for projects β€žon the other side of the worldβ€œ. To offset this amount of COβ‚‚, China could, for example, purchase around 15,000 hectares of Peruvian rainforest each year and place it under protection. 72 Secret Forest: Our protected area in Peru 🌐 https://wilderness-international.org/region/secret-forest   . Apart from a cost of 150 million euros, there is only one catch, which I will reveal to you with the last picture. – Andrzej Rostek / iStock by GettyImages

On the other hand: a society that is already much further ahead than many politicians and editorial offices are willing to admit. 83 percent are concerned about the consequences of climate change, 71 percent want more climate protection, and many companies and investors have long since strategically aligned themselves with a fossil-free future. 73 University of Bremen – β€žMajority of Germans willing to do more for climate protectionβ€œ 🌐 https://www.uni-bremen.de/universitaet/hochschulkommunikation-und-marketing/aktuelle-meldungen/detailansicht/forschungszentrum-gesellschaftlicher-zusammenhalt-mehrheit-der-deutschen-zu-mehr-klimaschutz-bereit 74 World Economic Forum – Climate adaptation finance β€˜running on empty’, and other nature news 🌐 https://www.weforum.org/stories/2025/11/climate-adaptation-finance-climate-nature-news/

This report highlights both the structural violence of a system that is far too slow and the real power of a majority that is capable of organising itself. β€žFossil fuel blockers are slowing things down – society has long since moved onβ€œ is therefore more than just a review of COP30. It is a pretty clear β€žcome onβ€œ to all of us who are somewhere in that 83 per cent: don't let anyone convince you that you are part of a small, hysterical minority. You are the majority. And it is precisely this majority that must now become loud, uncomfortable and united – in local politics, the media, the economy, movements, in your everyday life. 


Because if COP30 has shown us one thing, it is this: minimal diplomatic consensus will not save us. What can save us is a society that makes it clear to those blocking progress on fossil fuels that their time is up – and that is prepared to stand up for a fair and socially just climate policy.


 

Photo: The Huaneng Dezhou Power Station is a large coal-fired power station in the Decheng District of Dezhou, Shandong, China. 75 Huaneng Dezhou power station 🌐 https://www.gem.wiki/Huaneng_Dezhou_power_station With an installed capacity of around 2.5–2.7 GW, the plant currently has only half as much power as Waigaoqiao Power Station. 76 Huaneng Dezhou Coal Power Plant, China 🌐 https://globalenergyobservatory.org/geoid/41854 But that's almost twice as much power as the 1.41 GW from Germany's largest nuclear power plant, Isar II, near Munich. Just to highlight the dimensions. Okay, the comparison is a bit flawed, because Dezhou is a multi-unit coal-fired power station complex, Isar II, on the other hand, was a single reactor block – That is why the total output of Dezhou is significantly higher, even though each individual block there has less output than the Isar reactor. 77 Dezhou Coal-Fired Power Plant – The Dezhou project has added another 1,320MW to the existing coal-fired plant in Dezhou, China. The expansion was completed in 2003, and gives the plant a total capacity of 2,520MW. 🌐 https://www.power-technology.com/projects/dezhou/ chuyu / iStock by GettyImages

I promised you some more impressive figures. Here they are.

China currently operates around 1,160 coal-fired power stations – more than any other country in the world.78 statista: Countries and territories with the largest number of operational coal power plants worldwide as of July 2025 🌐 https://www.statista.com/statistics/859266/number-of-coal-power-plants-by-country/ . It is currently building around 50 more. 79 carbonbrief: CHINA POLICY 13 February 2025 – China’s construction of new coal-fired power plants β€˜reached a 10-year high’ in 2024 🌐 https://www.carbonbrief.org/chinas-construction-of-new-coal-power-plants-reached-10-year-high-in-2024/ and has another 30 to 50 additional facilities in the planning stage 80 Boom and Bust Coal 2025 🌐 https://globalenergymonitor.org/report/boom-and-bust-coal-2025/ 81 Boom and Bust Coal 2025 – Tracking the Global Coal Plant Pipeline, April 2025 🌐 https://globalenergymonitor.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/Boom-Bust-Coal-2025.pdf 82 CREA, Centre for Energy and Clean Air: Global Energy Monitor: When coal won’t step aside: The challenge of scaling clean energy in China, 02/2025 🌐 https://energyandcleanair.org/wp/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/CREA_GEM_China_Coal-power_H2-2024_FINAL.pdf 83 China sets new records in coal power plant approvals – Editorial Team, 13 February 2025 🌐 https://www.rinnovabili.net/policy-and-affairs/chinas-coal-power-plants-record-approvals-and-new-construction/

These figures are only surpassed – drum roll – by those for renewables. Which brings us, who would have thought, to a positive conclusion:

In China, with 339 GW of solar, wind and other renewable energy capacity currently under construction, this is more than three times the total capacity of fossil fuel projects under construction, which amount to 94.5 GW of coal-fired capacity. 84 rinnovabili.net – The unstoppable growth of renewables in China: 339 GW already on site 🌐 https://www.rinnovabili.net/business/the-unstoppable-growth-of-renewables-in-china-339-gw-already-on-site/

Fun fact: China is also expanding renewable energy more than Germany operates across all technologies combined. All German power plants together currently have an installed capacity of around 265,000 MW (265 GW).85 Federal Network Agency: List of power stations 🌐 https://www.bundesnetzagentur.de/DE/Fachthemen/ElektrizitaetundGas/Versorgungssicherheit/Erzeugungskapazitaeten/Kraftwerksliste/start.html . Of this, around 177–190 GW, or around 70%, comes from renewable energies (primarily wind and solar) in the electricity mix, with the remainder coming from fossil fuel and other conventional power plants. 86 bundesnetzagentur.de – Federal Network Agency – Press – Expansion of renewable energies 2024 🌐 https://www.bundesnetzagentur.de/1043738 .

Statistic: Countries and territories with the largest number of operational coal power plants worldwide as of July 2025 | Statista
Find more statistics at Statista

Illustration: Statista: Countries and territories with the largest number of operational coal power plants worldwide as of July 2025. Editorial use. With kind permission from Statista 12 December 2025 87 statista: Countries and territories with the largest number of operational coal power plants worldwide as of July 2025 🌐 https://www.statista.com/statistics/859266/number-of-coal-power-plants-by-country/ . It is currently building around 50 more. 88

List of sources